Feedback craft
Good critique is specific, grounded, and usable
- Direct feedback toward the work, not the person.
- Tie each critique to a goal, scenario, user need, or standard.
- End with a decision, question, or next action.
Weak versus strong
Personal
Weak
Why would you design it like this?
Strong
The ranking reason is hard to find before choosing.
Vague
Weak
This feels off.
Strong
The user may not understand why option A is recommended.
Actionable
Weak
Make it better.
Strong
Test whether students can explain the recommendation in one sentence.