Core idea
Critique is not opinion delivery
- Opinion says what someone likes.
- Critique explains what helps or blocks a user goal.
- Standards make critique fairer, calmer, and more useful.
Opinion
Feedback floats around taste and personality.
- I like this
- This feels wrong
- Make it pop
Critique
Critique links observations to goals and decisions.
- User goal
- Visible evidence
- Actionable next step